| Idumea | 31 | S.M. | And am I born to die? | Davison
|
| Imandra | 134 | 11s | I love thee, my Saviour, I love thee, my Lord | Davison.
|
| Imandra New | 34b | 11s | Farewell, my dear brethren, the time is at hand
|
| Immensity | 319 | L.M. | There is a world we have not seen | Caldwell
|
| In That Morning | 194 | L.M. | Jesus, my all, to heav'n is gone | Wm. Walker
|
| Indian Convert | 133 | 8, 8, 6 | In de dark woods, no Indian nigh | Johnson
|
| Indian's Farewell | 25b | 6 lines 7s | When shall we all meet again | Wm. Walker
|
| Intercession | 324b | S.M. | The Lord is ris'n indeed | T. C. Moffett
|
| Interrogation | 249 | 7s | Hark! my soul, it is the Lord | Christopher
|
| Invitation | 2 | 8, 7, 4 | Come, ye sinners, poor and wretched | Wm. Walker
|
| Invitation New | 303 | 8, 7, 4 | Come, ye sinners, poor and wretched
|
| Invocation [1] | 72 | 7, 6, 7, 6, 7, 7, 7, 6 | Rise, my soul, and stretch thy wings
|
| Invocation [2] | 193b | 8, 7 | Jesus, grant us all a blessing
|
| Ionia | 165 | 7s | Children of the heavenly King | J. W. Belcher
|
| Isles of the South | 86 | 11s | Wake, Isles of the South! your redemption is near | Wm. Houser
|
